Haul roads
How to run a fair haul road dust control trial
Most haul road dust trials end with an impression: the road looked better, the drivers were happier, the water carts seemed less busy. An impression is easy to argue with. This guide sets out how to run a trial whose answer a mine can defend, whichever product it tests.
Why trials go wrong
A haul road changes from week to week for reasons that have nothing to do with a product. Rain falls or stops, the traffic moves to another bench, a grader passes, the water cart operator changes the routine. A trial that compares this month’s treated road with last month’s untreated road measures all of that at once.
Researchers at Curtin University noted in 2009 that, of the many products claimed to reduce dust and road maintenance, few had been through controlled, published field trials. A controlled trial on a mine’s own roads is the way to close that gap for the mine itself.
Set it up
- Choose matched sections. Pick at least two road sections with a similar material, grade and traffic, used by the same trucks. Treat one, and leave the other as an untreated control.
- Record a baseline. Before treating anything, record the measures below on both sections for a few weeks, so you know how they compare when nothing is different.
- Apply as the product needs. Follow the product’s method and the dose advised for your site. The 2007 SAIMM paper on dust palliatives warns that a spray-on treatment has to penetrate and build up depth, or traffic soon exposes untreated material.
- Run both sections over the same weeks. Compare treated against control over the same period, through at least one grading cycle, so the weather and the traffic are the same for both.
- Keep the routine honest. Water each section only when it needs it, by the same rule on both, and record every pass.
Measure what matters
- Water-cart loads per section per day: the simplest measure of how often a road needs water, and the one a mine already pays for.
- How long the dust stays down after each watering: time it, with the same observer and the same rule for “dusty” on both sections.
- Grader passes and spot repairs on each section.
- Rain, temperature and wind each day, and the traffic on each section, so a change in either can be seen in the results.
- Where the mine has them: dust monitor readings, and the trucks’ own fuel, payload and speed records on each section.
Read the result fairly
Compare the change on the treated section with the change on the control over the same weeks, not the treated section with itself last month. State the result with what it depends on: the road material, the traffic and the weather. A result from one road is a result for that road; another road may behave differently.
Taking it further
A dust trial can measure more than dust. With the trucks’ telemetry on the same sections, a mine can also see what the road’s condition does to fuel: see our paid haul road fuel and emissions study.
To compare the methods before choosing what to trial, see Haul road dust control: choosing a method.
Sources
- Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, vol. 107, July 2007, pp. 435 to 450. SAIMM (PDF).
- Curtin University, PATREC Research Forum paper, 1 October 2009. Curtin repository.
Contact
Tell us what you need.
Tell us the product, the quantities, the mine or site and its country, and the date you need it. Holding an RFQ or tender? Send it whole, and we reply to every line we supply.
E-mail info@88chemco.com · WhatsApp +27 84 556 8888 (opens WhatsApp)
Prices and deliveries outside South Africa are quoted with each order.